Entrecard’s Fundamental Flaw
I’ll start with this: The premise and design of Entrecard is brilliant. Graham Langdon has developed a great tool for promoting a blog and discovering other blogs. It has drawn a solid cadre of very experienced bloggers, from whom I’ve learned a great deal.
I’ve written about Entrecard a few times, so I’ll avoid doing yet another overview. What I’ve discovered is that the core concept of visit and drop has a fundamental flaw. This flaw is partially to blame for the higher normal bounce rate, but is more clearly felt on the forums with a regular, unanswered question.
Why visit a blog that doesn’t have any new content?
Entrecard users drop to earn credits and many of us return the favor by visiting their blogs and dropping back. We work our inboxes, often visiting sites that haven’t been posted to in weeks. Are they bloggers or droppers?
There have been a few “cultural movements” in the history of Entrecard that have distinctly highlighted this flaw. I’ll spend a bit of time discussing each one:
UDropIFollow
Initially, I thought this was a very good approach to Entrecard. Because I couldn’t fully commit to dropping on my droppers each day, I didn’t don the badge. But I didn’t try to work my inbox diligently.
I recently did a very unscientific experiment. I visited and dropped on the self-proclaimed founder of the UDropIFollow movement, Lee Doyle. I dropped using bot of the blogs I have at Entrecard. I did this for eight consecutive days. How many drops did that get me from Lee Doyle? Zero.
Wait? You mean the founder of the movement can’t or isn’t walking the walk? No, he isn’t. But maybe he was away? He was on the Entrecard forums regularly during the time I was doing this experiment. Maybe he gets more than 300 drops each day? Perhaps, but I did run this with two blog accounts for eight days. In the not so tactful language of my other blog, UDropIFollow is bullshit!
It isn’t enforceable. It isn’t sustainable. And it misses the true value of Entrecard. I considered carrying on the experiment a bit longer, or extending it to other bloggers, but other cultural movements at Entrecard woke me up.
Entrecard Bans Quick Drop Sites
When you’re dropping just to earn credits, quick drop sites rock! You get your credit they get their credit. Quick and easy just like a hand job in the alley. If credits are all you want, then Entrecard isn’t for you.
The ban and subsequent removal of the quick drop sites will do a lot to improve the quality at Entrecard. I applaud Graham and the crew’s efforts on this. I’m only now understanding this well enough to appreciate the ban.
Comment Bomb!
What if we collectively visited a blog with fresh, good content, read the post, dropped an Entrecard, and then wrote a comment? Novel idea? Not really. That is how I imagine Entrecard was initially envisioned. The results of the comment bomb were magnificent and energizing.
I felt a spark of home emerge. What had become a chore with a hint of addiction, now had a much more pleasant aroma. A glow of promise where 300 drops per account wasn’t a goal, but was a commitment to the community.
Digg Community of Entrecard
Graham next posed the suggestion that we form a collective Digg by Entrecarders. I had always seen Digg as a big tool for a small blog, unwieldy and cumbersome. But as a collective, we could do something cool. We aren’t one small blog, we are a network of thousands of blogs. The forums and comment bomb had made us a community. I now had over 250 friends on Digg (in a single day). With careful management (Digg will ban you for violating their TOS) this could be very powerful.
Then the shouting started. The incessant shouting! “Look here!” “Please, Digg this!” I taught my daughter that if she begged me for something she wouldn’t get it. It goes the same for me with Digg. Why on Earth should I Digg a post that consists solely of a YouTube video the blogger didn’t make?
So here we are. What did we learn?
Dropping for the sake of dropping isn’t productive and degrades the Entrecard community. While the premise of UDropIFollow is noble, in practice it isn’t working. There is a community here, but mining the value of that takes focus.
To make Entrecard matter, we as a network have to start where all great Internet media does, excellent content. We need a constant stream of blog posts that entertain and/or educate.
How do we do that? I don’t know if a technical solution exists. It starts with the users. We have to stop rewarding stale blogs.
Here is my approach:
- If you drop on me, or get my attention on the forums or on Twitter, I will subscribe to your RSS feed.
- Through my RSS reader (Bloglines), I will drop from at least one of my blog accounts on the blogs that have new posts.
- If you have written a good post, I’ll Digg, Stumble, Reddit, etc. If the Entrecard community is behind you, it is likely I will be too.
- At least once per month, I will post a “featured” (i.e., relevant) blog posts I found and enjoyed, with full backlinks.
Entertain and/or educate me and I’ll pay you back.
I moved my Entrecard widget to the sidebar “above the fold” because I believe in the Entrecard community. I hope you’ll join me in pushing mediocrity out of the system. Are you a blogger or a dropper?





Have you ever gone to a blog and seen comments where the commenter has their picture next to their comment? At first, I thought this was just how blogger or wordpress.com rewarded their members. Mine would always be a gray blob or a gray square smiley face. Well, it wasn’t something they did, it was something the commenter had done.

